Ewe's Dream Romano Style

Otterbein (Cumberland Co.)

Sheep Cheeses

A Romano type grateable cheese made from fresh, raw, whole sheep's milk. A farmstead cheese produced in Newburg, Cumberland County, PA. This cheese is aged twenty months, creating a smooth and delicious Romano style, and becoming very sharp with age.

15lb wheel

​

Kid's Delight Tomme Style

Otterbein (Cumberland Co.)

Goat Cheeses

A Tomme style table cheese made from fresh, raw, whole goat milk. A farmstead cheese produced in Newburg, Cumberland County, PA. The cheese is aged 4 months to a year, producing a cheese with a buttery, nutty rich flavor.

5lb wheel

​

Shepherd's Delight Tomme Style

Otterbein (Cumberland Co.)

Sheep Cheeses

Otterbein Acres' Shepherd's Delight is a Pennsylvania Farm Show Blue Ribbon Cheese and an American Cheese Society 1st Place Award Winning Cheese. Sheherd's Delight is a Tomme style table cheese reminiscent of farmer's cheese made and eaten on the farm. This cheese is remarkable for its simplicity and essential place in the rythyms of everyday life. Its production recycles leftover milk and its flavor is satisfying and honest. This everyday cheese has a flavor far apart from a common everyday grocery cheese. It has a sharp taste and a firm texture, and is made from fresh, raw, whole sheep's milk. Its seasoned appearance is due to the aging process which takes place in a cave and ranges from 4-12 months. The microflora in cave-aging creates the earthy rind. The "tomme-iness" or aroma is not unlike the cave it is aged in: Rustic, earthy, and loamy. This Tomme cheese is made during the summer months when the sheep are grazing on sun-warmed sweet grasses. Shepherd's Delight Tomme is an exceptional, satisfying cheese, something to eat and enjoy on a daily basis. Wines such as Cabernet Sauvingnon, Syrah, and Zinfandel match deliciously with Shepherd's Delight. This table cheese rests well on a sideboard at room temperature where it is accessible for all day quick snacking. Find a place for this award winning cheese on your cheese or charcuterie board as it never disappoints. It shines on a natural grain cracker with a dollop of sweet fig preserves. Shave some on a salad overflowing with fresh seasonal vegetables or pack in a lunch with sweet juicy berries and crunchy nuts.

5lb wheel

​

Sheep Creamy Delight Camembert

Roundtop Farm

Sheep Cheeses

A clean, crisp, and bright cheese from our own herd of ewes, this selection features camembert's rich and creamy style. It features a warm finish that brings sweet corn to mind.

7oz wheel

​

Sheep Milk Bleu

Roundtop Farm

Sheep Cheeses

Try our nutty and powerful blue cheese! You'll discover notes of everything from toasted nuts to roast coffee in a cheese that goes wonderfully with dark chocolate.

5lb wheel

​

Roundtop's Delight Tomme

Roundtop Farm

Sheep Cheeses

Tomme has a smooth, firm texture and buttery, nutty flavor. It melts really well and grates easily, so try in a grilled cheese sandwich or in a fondue.

5lb wheel

​

Sheepy Lovely Feta

Roundtop Farm

Sheep Cheeses

This tart, slightly herbaceous feta is made from sheep's milk and gives you a long-lasting finish that is smooth, rich, and pronounced! Try it with olives and dark greens.

5lb wheel

​

Goat's Creamy Delight Camembert

Roundtop Farm

Goat Cheeses

Goat Camembert is a lovely cheese with bloomy-rind. It has a luscious tangy paste with a buttery finish. This is a versatile cheese partner for many wines, particularly the lighter varieties.

7oz wheel

​

Goat Cheddar

Misty Creek

Goat Cheeses

Traditionally made with cow's milk and the USA's second most popular cheese (behind Mozzarella), this goat milk version is a versatile and soft-spoken cheese. This mild cheese is perfectly suited for any occasion, as it's sure to be enjoyed by all.

5lb block

​

Colby

Misty Creek

Goat Cheeses

Colby is a sub-variety of Cheddar and one of only a few cheese types that originated in the US. This is a very mild cheese, firm and hearty. An ideal first cheese to introduce the pleasures of goat cheese to a timid cheese eater. It has a bounciness of texture not unlike a deli-case Muenster, and a soft pleasing tang on the tongue.

5lb block

​

Smoked Cheddar

Misty Creek

Goat Cheeses

This is a cheese many tasters call their favorite of ours. The smoke flavor on this cheese is smooth, clean, and natural tasting. Tasters often tell us that they expected not to like it and were pleasantly surprised to discover that a new favorite had been found.

5lb block

​

Monterey Hot Jack

Misty Creek

Goat Cheeses

Don't let the name and the look scare you - the cheese really tones down the habanero. Taster said: "Stand down, tall glass of water." And: "It looks like a lot to handle with all the pretty red chinks and swirls, but it's really quite gentle.

5lb block

​

Garlic and Chives

Misty Creek

Goat Cheeses

This is a party cheese. Great cubed on a tray, it also has a lot of potential uses in the kitchen. A great all purpose cheese that any garlic fan should always have on hand.

5lb block

​

Wine and Goat Cheddar

Misty Creek

Goat Cheeses

With just a hint of wine flavor, this is a perfect cheese for entertaining, This is a mild-flavored cheese that will appeal to everyone.

5lb block

​

O’ My Peppercorn Colby

Misty Creek

Goat Cheeses

A deliciously snack-able cheese that looks like it's more peppery than it tastes. A mild cheese that everyone should enjoy, and many will keep coming back to taste.

5lb block

​

Misty Lovely

Misty Creek

Goat Cheeses

One of our most loved, and most versatile cheeses. If you like feta, you'll love Misty Lovely. The flavor is clean, fresh, salty, bright, cheery, and zesty. Misty Lovely crumbles easily and melts in your mouth.

5lb wheel

​

Mist O’ Bleu

Misty Creek

Goat Cheeses

A nice, solid bleu cheese with a twangy, tingly pow. Salty at first, then the bleu really comes through. Tasters said: "Fun to wait for the bleu flavor to come through."

5lb wheel

​

Kid Chego

Misty Creek

Goat Cheeses

A goat milk version fo the Spanish cheese Manchego that is traditionally made with milk from sheep. This cheese has a firm, compact consistency and a smooth texture. While mild in flavor, this is a cheese that's rich in a simple way; it's savory, soft, and substantial.

5lb wheel

​

Midnight Dream

Misty Creek

Goat Cheeses

This delightful and special cheese is washed with port wine.

5lb wheel

​

Tomme De Conestoga

Misty Creek

Goat Cheeses

This is a smooth, mild and creamy cheese with earthy/green and nitty notes. This cheese has more complexity of flavor than a Cheddar or Colby. There is a faint funk to the rind, and this versatile cheese should be enjoyable to almost everyone.

5lb block

​

Paradise Colby

Alpine Heritage

Cow Cheeses

Aged approx 2-6 months. A classic farmstead Colby with a smooth buttery flavor and grassy aroma that comes from our 100% grass fed organic Jersey milk. A classic snacking cheese with a wide variety of applications from mac and cheese to your next cheese plate.

5lb block

​

Dutch Country Swiss

Alpine Heritage

Cow Cheeses

Approx 3-8 months old. This Alpine Heritage Swiss cheese is unique in that it boasts the rich, creamy aroma of our Jersey milk and a mild, almost sweet flavor. Perfect for melting or as a simple snack with crackers or some nice crusty bread.

5lb block

​

Mild Cheddar

Alpine Heritage

Cow Cheeses

Aged approx 2-4 months. This young cheddar is as perfect melted on a turkey club as it is on your next cheese plate with candied nuts and grapes.

5lb block

​

Paradise Cheddar

Alpine Heritage

Cow Cheeses

Aged approx 6-10 months. This medium cheddar is for those who prefer a bolder flavor. Still smooth but with a bigger bite at the finish. Great with cured meats and as a sandwich cheese.

5lb block

​

Johnny’s Clothbound Cheddar

Alpine Heritage

Cow Cheeses

Approx 14-20 months old. An Alpine Heritage original with a big, long lasting flavor. Traditional English cloth binding and cave aging brings our 100% grass fed Jersey milk to life! Notes of everything from pineapple to root vegetables come together in this complex cheese.

20lb wheel

​

Paradise Reserve

Alpine Heritage

Cow Cheeses

Aged approx 1-2 years. A full bodied Cheddar with a complex flavor. Smooth and buttery up front but with the classic Cheddar bite on the finish, all with a tangy aroma that comes from the creamy milk of our 100% grass fed Jersey cows. Great melted or accompanied by figs and green grapes on your next cheese plate.

5lb block

​

Applewood Cheddar

Alpine Heritage

Cow Cheeses

Aged approx 4-8 months. Our signature Cheddar smoked over apple wood for a more robust flavor. The hint of smoke makes this cheese ideal with cured meats, pickled vegetables and melted over a burger or in a grilled cheese

5lb block

​

Pepper Jack

Alpine Heritage

Cow Cheeses

Aged approx 2-6 months. A tart and spicy Pepper Jack with just the right amount of heat. Just enough chiles to give you a little kick but not so many that they overwhelm your palette or our creamy grass fed Jersey milk. An ideal melter.

5lb block

​

Garlic Cheddar

Alpine Heritage

Cow Cheeses

Aged approx 4-8 months. Our signature cheddar with the addition of organic granulated garlic powder and dried chives. A powerful cheese with a flavor that finds a balance between the flavor of garlic and the creamy rich flavors found in our Jersey milk. The perfect cheese to top your burgers.

5lb block

​

Herbal Jack

Alpine Heritage

Cow Cheeses

Aged approx 2-6 months. Our classic Jack recipe with the addition of a mild Italian herb and aromatic dill weed mixture. Prefect for your next grilled cheese or alongside sliced apples and pears on a cheese plate.

5lb block

​

PA Dutch Feta

Alpine Heritage

Cow Cheeses

Aged approx 6-12 months. Our cow milk feta is the perfect cheese for your summer salad. Our feta has a big sharp flavor to it while still maintaining the creaminess of 100% grass fed Jersey milk. Great with bright watermelon and grilled veggies.

5lb block

​

Yogurt Cheese

Alpine Heritage

Cow Cheeses

Aged approx 2-6 months. A classic cheese with a nice springy texture. A sweet aroma reminiscent of warm butter. Mild but with a full round flavor and a tangyness that makes it an ideal partner for cured meats or pickles.

5lb block

​

Cheddar

Green Ridge Farm

Cow Cheeses

Aged 2-6 months. This full flavored cheese is as perfect melted on a turkey club as it is on your cheese platter.

5lb block

​

Smoked Cheddar

Green Ridge Farm

Cow Cheeses

Aged 3-8 months. Naturally smoked making a full smoked flavor. A great snack cheese or to add depth to sandwiches.

5lb block

​

Garlic + Chive Cheddar

Green Ridge Farm

Cow Cheeses

Aged 3-8 months. This is a powerful cheese with a flavor that finds a balance between garlic and the creamy rich sweetness found in our Jersey cow milk.

5lb block

​

Colby

Green Ridge Farm

Cow Cheeses

Aged 2-6 months. This is a traditional Colby that has a unique flavor that is simply delicious.

5lb block

​

Herbal Jack

Green Ridge Farm

Cow Cheeses

Aged 3-6 months. A classic jack cheese with the addition of a blend of mild Italian herbs and aromatic dill weed. Great as a grilled cheese or with salad.

5lb block

​

Pepper Jack

Green Ridge Farm

Cow Cheeses

Aged 3-6 months. A tart and spicy combo with just the right amount of heat, but not to much to overwhelm the creamy rich flavor found in our Jersey cow milk.

5lb block

​

Swiss

Green Ridge Farm

Cow Cheeses

Aged 3-6 months. This great tasting cheese is unique in that it's a whole milk Swiss, and not as dry as traditional with a pleasant zing at the finish.

5lb block

​

Lancaster Bleu

Misty Creek

Cow Cheeses

This bleu begins its journey at 3 months of age, and is well balanced by 6 months. Its biggest bleu flavor arrives at 8 months.

5lb wheel

​